Florida denies defying the judge in a case on blocking medical care for transgender people

Share
lgbtq
Protestors march against a bill restricting transgender girls from sports teams in Pierre, South Dakota on Thursday, March 11. (Toby Brusseau/AP Images for Human Rights Campaign)

By Jim Saunders ©2023 The News Service of Florida

TALLAHASSEE — Gov. Ron DeSantis’ administration Wednesday disputed allegations that it has defied a federal judge’s decision in a battle about state attempts to block Medicaid coverage for transgender people seeking hormone therapy and puberty blockers.

Plaintiffs’ attorneys on Oct. 4 asked U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle to enforce a June decision that invalidated a state law and a rule “to the extent they categorically ban Medicaid payment for puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones for the treatment of gender dysphoria.”

The attorneys contended the state has continued to enforce the rule in “complete defiance of the judgment.”

But in a 10-page response Wednesday, lawyers for the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration argued the state is not enforcing the rule as a “categorical ban” on coverage for the treatments. That is because Medicaid patients could seek variances or waivers of the rule through an administrative process.

“Given the continued ability of Medicaid-eligible gender dysphoria patients to petition for a variance or waiver on a case-by-case basis, the (state) defendants are not enforcing (the rule) as a categorical ban on Medicaid coverage for hormonal treatments for gender dysphoria,” the response said. “It follows that there is no need for an order to enforce the court’s final judgment.”

But in the Oct. 4 filing, attorneys for the plaintiffs called such arguments a “red herring” and said, for example, that the Agency for Health Care Administration has told Medicaid managed-care organizations to deny coverage for such treatments. Most Medicaid beneficiaries are enrolled in managed-care plans.

“In short, the denials of coverage and instructions to MCOs (managed-care organizations) are categorical, and defendants have announced their intent to continue to enforce this categorical ban on Medicaid coverage of puberty blockers and hormones as treatment for gender dysphoria despite this court having deemed it unconstitutional and unlawful,” the plaintiff’s filing said.

The lawsuit was filed last year on behalf of two transgender adults and the parents of two transgender minors after the Agency for Health Care Administration adopted the rule. The lawsuit was updated this spring to also include a new state law aimed at preventing Medicaid coverage for the treatments.

Hinkle in June ruled that the law and the rule violated constitutional equal-protection rights, a federal Medicaid law and a federal Affordable Care Act prohibition on sex discrimination.

Part of the decision ordered the Agency for Health Care Administration to provide Medicaid coverage for the four plaintiffs in the case. But part of it also more broadly invalidated the law and the rule “to the extent they categorically ban Medicaid payment.”

The state has appealed Hinkle’s decision to the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and has not tried to move forward with the law that DeSantis and the Republican-led Legislature approved this spring. But it has continued to use the rule approved last year, while pointing to the possibility of patients receiving variances or waivers.

In the filing Wednesday, the state’s lawyers disputed the plaintiffs’ allegation that the argument about variances or waivers is a “red herring.”

“Based on the logic of this court’s final judgment, a gender dysphoria patient may be able to obtain a variance or waiver of (the rule) if he or she demonstrates that a multidisciplinary team of providers of the type referenced by this court has determined that hormonal treatment is medically necessary and that refusal of Medicaid coverage for such treatment would create substantial hardship under the particular circumstances at hand,” the state’s lawyers wrote.

But in the Oct. 4 court document, the plaintiffs’ attorneys urged Hinkle to enforce the judgment by instructing the state that it cannot use the rule to bar Medicaid coverage for the treatments.

“The rule, on its face, categorically excludes from Medicaid coverage all gender-affirming medical treatment, including puberty-delaying medications and hormones,” the plaintiffs’ attorneys wrote. “And, on its face, the rule has no exceptions.”

DeSantis and many other Republican leaders across the country have made a priority in recent years of trying to restrict treatments for people with gender dysphoria. The federal government defines gender dysphoria clinically as “significant distress that a person may feel when sex or gender assigned at birth is not the same as their identity.”

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

You may also like

A woman in a green jacket speaking into a microphone. She has headphone on and is seated inside of a radio station studio where a background that says "WMNF 88.5 FM" in the background.
Pinellas State Rep. Lindsay Cross talks hurricane recovery, a holistic approach to conversation, and more

“You can’t underestimate the toll it takes on people’s mental...

The Scoop: Thur. Dec 12, 2024, Tampa Bay and Florida headlines by WMNF

Get the latest updates on Florida lawmakers and their actions....

TBT’s Stephanie Hayes Breaks It Down For You

Nationally syndicated columnist, Stephanie Hayes of the Tampa Bay Times...

The holidays mean peak season for U.S. Postal Service

Listen: People ship gifts, cards, and packages nationwide as the...

Ways to listen

WMNF is listener-supported. That means we don't advertise like a commercial station, and we're not part of a university.

Ways to support

WMNF volunteers have fun providing a variety of needed services to keep your community radio station alive and kickin'.

The Sixties Show
Player position: