House passes Dream Act, Senate delays its vote

12/09/10 Seán Kinane
WMNF Drive-Time News Thursday | Listen to this entire show:


Last night the U.S. House of Representatives passed the Dream Act, but a vote was delayed in the Senate this morning. The act would give conditional green cards to undocumented immigrants if they graduate from high school and pursue college or a job in the military. They could eventually apply for citizenship if they meet all requirements. Opponents, like Louisiana Republican Senator David Vitter, don’t want these undocumented immigrants to have a path to citizenship.

"The Dream Act is a major amnesty provision. There are no two ways about it. It grants at least 2.1 million 'illegals' amnesty and it puts them on a path towards citizenship which will also allow them to have their family members put in legal status in this country. That means when you count all of those people there are probably two to three times that initial 2.1 million people who will be granted some form of amnesty. When we're not securing our borders adequately, when we're not putting a system in place to enforce workplace security I think that is absolutely wrong."

Because of objections like that from Republicans, Democrats decided on the delay because they do not have the 60 votes needed to advance the bill. Supporters, like Senator Dick Durbin, say that kids brought into the country shouldn’t be punished for the actions of their parents.

"We owe it to the young men and women who's lives will be affected, we owe it to America who needs their service in the military and needs their skill in building our economy. To honestly address this issue and ask members of both sides to sit down, pause and reflect as to whether or not we can afford to say to these talented young men and women there's no place in America for you. There is a place. There's a place for them as there was a place for my mother who came to this country at the age of 2 as an immigrant, who's mother and father could barely speak the English language, but who eventually gave birth to a son who stands here today as a Senator from the State of Illinois. My story is an American story. The story of these Dream Act students is an American story."

Durbin is a Democrat from Illinois and the Majority Whip.

Over in the House last night, Tampa-area member of Congress Kathy Castor voted with the majority to support the Dream Act.

“Our country is built upon a foundation of equality, liberty and opportunity. These values apply to all except a small group of young people who for no fault of their own have been stuck in limbo and face obstacles to education and productivity. The Dream Act will breathe new life into their hopes and dreams and the economies of our local communities.”

Representative Castor is a Democrat. Senate Democrats will wait until after considering bills to fund the government and extend tax cuts. Then they’ll consider the same version of the Dream Act passed by the House last night.

Previous WMNF coverage of the Dream Act

comments powered by Disqus



What reason is there, other then blatant racism. To deny immigrants the chance to either serve the country they grew up in, go to school, join the middle to upper class workforce, become taxpaying citizens, and thus helping to reduce the huge deficit?

Damn racists’… they’re everywhere, they’re

Republicans have pointed out that the legislation doesn't REQUIRE illegal immigrants to get or have a high school or college degree… and… that it also allows illegal immigrants to be eligible for citizenship even if they have several convictions on their record. Even the House version had 3 dozen Democrats vote against it… something’s got to be wrong with it.


Forgive me if I'm a little skeptical of whatever excuses they come up with to vote against it. I'd like to see it for myself first. After all there are racists amongst Republicans and Democrats alike. It doesn't make sense to me that there are no prerequisites at all. Which means they would be handing out citizenship to just anyone. Also unless it's a felony conviction I don't see it as a big issue. Especially if the individuals are trying to better themselves by pursuing an education or military career.

Flashbacks are cool...

You’re right… we would be handing out citizenships to just anyone. In 1986 the “Dream Act” was called the “Immigration Reform and Control Act”. Just for 1 minute… let’s assume that there is no REQUIREMENT in the “Dream Act” to have a high school degree… if I’m not too badly mistaken… you must have a high school degree (or equivalent) in order to join any branch of the US Military or be accepted to any college. So… if an illegal immigrant can’t serve… or pursue a higher education… how will the vast majority of them… contribute to anything… other than our population growth??? Also… felony arrests are regularly plea-bargained down to misdemeanor convictions. Dude… there aint nothing racist about this… it’s called "common sense".

still sketchy

I'm not going to speculate on the hypothetical. As it's presented I don't see a problem with it. Like I said I have to see it for myself. I will remain skeptical until then. If it turns out that what's being said is true. Then obviously that defeats the whole purpose of the bill in the first place. Because the point of it was that there are a lot of kids out there who want to go to college or enlist in the military but can't. They have already been through the public school system but don't want to settle. Which means the money has already been spent educating them. But they want more than that. Chances are, they aren't going anywhere and will probably end up working a low paying job..Like I said, the concept of it is good, as it's intended.

I'll read it also...