Mary O’Connor is confirmed as Tampa Police Chief after a heated debate, accusations of a flawed process and a 4-2 vote

Tampa Police Department
Mary O'Connor speaks before Tampa City Council before confirmation vote. CTTV screenshot, 17 March 2022.

Mary O’Connor was confirmed as Tampa Police Chief Thursday on a vote of 4-2. The vote came after more than two hours of mixed public comment and strong words from some members of Tampa City Council that the nomination process was secretive and worse.

Public comment

Most people who spoke during public comment were affiliated with Tampa Police Department and most of them urged City Council to confirm O’Connor.

But several members of the public opposed her, including Yvette Lewis, president of the NAACP Hillsborough branch.

“African-Americans in this community were targeted with ticketing and arrest for riding a bike under Mary O’Connor’s leadership.

Tampa City Council, you asked, ‘why do we keep bringing Biking While Black up?’

It’s because the wounds are still there. The wounds are still present. Later to discover more wounds were opened, slashed with the ‘Crime Free Housing‘ program targeted African-Americans and poor people in the City of Tampa.”

-Yvette Lewis, NAACP Hillsborough branch

(Lewis is a member of the WMNF Board of Directors.)

O’Connor’s confirmation was supported by City Council members Joseph Citro, Guido Maniscalco, Charlie Miranda and Luis Viera. She was opposed by Bill Carlson and Orlando Gudes.

Opposition by Carlson and Gudes

Carlson didn’t pull any punches about his anger at the nomination and confirmation process. He accused the administration of Mayor Jane Castor of playing dirty, even suggesting that it leaked information that led to the recent resignation of former Council member John Dingfelder.

After his “no” vote, Carlson told the media assembled, “if you see a negative story about either of us [who voted against O’Connor] in the next week, please ask the [mayor’s] administration about that.” Carlson said, “democracy is at risk in this city.”

Gudes, who is Black and a former Tampa Police officer, noted that he didn’t see any Black officers supporting O’Connor. Gudes said he felt disrespected by the process.

O’Connor’s four priorities

Before the vote, O’Connor said she would focus on four priorities:

“Number one, I want to work side-by-side with all community members.

Number two, I want to ensure that the Tampa Police Department officers have a very robust safety and wellness program available to them.

Number three, I want to reduce violent crime. But I also want to reduce all crime.

And number four, I believe in having a strong quality-assurance platform in place to ensure everyone in this city is treated with dignity and respect that they deserve.”

-Mary O’Connor, who was confirmed as Tampa Police Chief

Carlson calls for respect from Mayor Castor’s administration

Before the vote, Carlson emphasized some of what he saw wrong in the process.

“The private sector can do whatever they want. But when the [mayor’s] administration works to sabotage a sitting City Council member — several sitting City Council members — they leak information that causes a City Council member to have to resign, that is despicable.

The public wants the administration to stop the attacks. They want the administartion to stop the politics. They want the administration to stop the conspiracy theories, stop divisiveness and stop the controversies.

We need to have democracy in our community. We need to work together.

And guess what happens, by the way, when you vote ‘Yes’ because you want to get on the good side of the administration? I voted ‘Yes’ on [a city construction project on] Hanna Avenue. So did Dingfelder. It’s one of the worst public policy things in the history of the City of Tampa. And guess what happened? We still got attacked and Dingfelder’s no longer on City Council.

I would ask the administration to start over [the process of selecting a police chief], be respectful of the public, be respectful of City Council. Let’s be respectful of the balance of powers in this community. And let’s be respectful of democracy in this country.”

-Tampa City Council member Bill Carlson

You may also like

srq new college
AAUP sanctions New College of Florida after politically motivated “egregious and extensive violations”

AAUP, a major American academic association made up of faculty...

Show your support for the Sustainable Living Show during this week’s FUNd drive.

Tampa Bay, it’s time to show some love! Love for...

Gov. DeSantis sends more Florida Highway Patrol and National Guardsmen to southern border

Governor Ron DeSantis announced Florida Highway Patrol and National Guardsman...

Need a passport? A Passport Fair is being held Saturday

The Tampa Post Office will be hosting a Passport Fair....

Ways to listen

WMNF is listener-supported. That means we don't advertise like a commercial station, and we're not part of a university.

Ways to support

WMNF volunteers have fun providing a variety of needed services to keep your community radio station alive and kickin'.

Follow us on Instagram

Democracy Now!
Player position: