Tampa Police Chief: 100% certain Seminole Heights murderer arrested; Mayor: “he should die”


Tampa Police Chief Brian Dugan says he is “100%” confident they have arrested the man who committed four murders in the Southeast Seminole Heights neighborhood over the past two months. Dugan says the major break in the case came when Howell Emanuel Donaldson III handed a bag to one of his managers at a McDonald’s restaurant in Ybor City on Tuesday.

Dugan spoke at a press conference Wednesday morning at the Seminole Heights Garden Center. Dugan says the state attorney has not decided whether to seek the death penalty. For his part, Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn says that the judicial process should take its course, but that if Donaldson is found guilty, “he should die.”

Father of Seminole Heights murder victim
Casimar Naiboa, father of Seminole Heights murder victim. By Seán Kinane / WMNF News (29 Nov 2017).

Dugan says the suspect, Donaldson, admitted he owned the gun, which he bought a few days before the first murder, but did not give much other information.

Donaldson has been charged with four counts of first degree murder.

Dugan says he did not think Donaldson was trying to get caught or turn himself in by giving the bag with the gun to his McDonald’s coworker. Dugan says Donaldson’s mental state “seemed fine.”

The arrest report provided by Tampa Police says the “F.D.L.E. and A.T.F. analysis of the fired cartridge casings, which were recovered from all four [crime] scenes, identified the casings as being fired in the same firearm … a Glock .40 caliber handgun.”

Despite an ad for a reward for information leading to the arrest of the Seminole Heights murderer (who was still at large), a person sleeps on a bench at a bus stop in Southeast Seminole Heights, Tampa. By Seán Kinane (27 Nov 2017).

The arrest report says Donaldson let the police search his phone and it indicated that his phone location data “correspond with the dates and times of the first three murders.”

According to the arrest report, during a search of his car that Donaldson consented to, police found “a suspected blood stain on an area of the clothing” similar to the clothing the suspect is seen wearing in surveillance video before and after the first murder.

Listen to the full press conference here:

Facebook live video of press conference, which starts around seven-minute mark:

Here are the first two pages of the arrest report:

Seminole Heights Murder arrest Seminole Heights murders arrest report








Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office booking video of Donaldson:


Here’s another video of the press conference:

part 2:


You may also like

Political Violence, Rhetoric and the Vote

Patró Mabíli leads a sobering discussion about the state of...

Woman dies while working at a Polk County Mosaic plant

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration is still investigating a...

A ballot initiative to expand Medicaid in Florida gets $250,000

Hoping to pass a Florida constitutional amendment in 2026 expanding...

The Scoop: Mon. July 15th, 2024 Tampa Bay and Florida headlines by WMNF

Trump was shot at a rally in Pennsylvania, as the...

Ways to listen

WMNF is listener-supported. That means we don't advertise like a commercial station, and we're not part of a university.

Ways to support

WMNF volunteers have fun providing a variety of needed services to keep your community radio station alive and kickin'.

Follow us on Instagram

It's The Music Monday
Player position: